Labels

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Size (Does Matter)

I'm still testing toxins and pincers: The scripts are taking a long time to run (maybe I need to reboot?) and I'm concerned about data quality for some of the toxin results (two unlike--but similar toxins came out identically powered for the 32 AP test and that ... makes me wonder).

But in other news, I'm working on a plan for Size.

Size
In JAGS the way you play a grizzly bear or a giant or a godzilla (correctly called a Kiaju--the genus of those things) is by buying Size to make you bigger. This is in addition to getting claws and teeth, a huge club, or nuclear breath. Size is like "Strength" except:

  • You MUST have at least 1 STR per 5 BLD.
  • You MUST have at least +1 DP per 1 BLD.
  • You get bonuses To-Be-Hit (which may vary depending on if the attack is Ranged or HTH) as you get bigger
  • You get +1 CON above some level (roughly the weight of a tiger)
  • You get more 'Stride' in the form of bonuses to ground movement
  • Your bio-weapons (or just fists) get more Reach
  • You may get +1 Large Weapon Bonuses to hit things that are smaller (there are some optional rules around this)
This is all pretty complex. Let's see a simple example:

Example: I am creating a creature that weighs 300lbs and I plan to get that by buying Size (aside: there are other ways to get BLD and such, but Size is the most complete package). I start with a base character that weighs 150lbs. I need 150lbs of Size. So here's what that's like: (1) It will require 10 BLD (150 lbs). That means the package MUST also come with +2 STR and +10 DP. If I can just "buy Size by the BLD-pt" then I get +10 BLD and the package must include the other stats. (2) I can see on a chart that this size gives me +1 to be hit at Range and gives me a modest stride increase. (3) There is no Reach or CON increase and my humanoid size, if I am humanoid, is estimated at 6'6".
Okay, so how do you "sell Size"?

Selling Size
The JAGS convention is that Traits usually cost either 4 or 8 AP per level (it's not a rule but it's a guideline) and if you are buying STR/BLD you must specify whether the character will be Armed or Unarmed. The question is: "Does the character commonly use a PEN-damage HTH attack?" If yes, you pay the Armed cost and if not you get the Unarmed Cost.

So far, so good.

The problems here are as follows:

  • My costing-methodology works very well for attacks but we have never tried it out with the mix of attacks (STR/BLD) and Defenses (DP). I'm testing now to see what happens and by the end of this post maybe I'll have some stats for the preliminary run.
  • None of this tells us how to cost for +'s to be hit and CON (both of these are, costed correctly, a percentage of your TOTAL AP points). 
  • As we would like to sell Size "by the BLD-pt" that breaks the 4/8 AP rule pretty immediately.
Decisions About Unarmed Size
I have to determine what my "rule" will be for Unarmed Size. As stated above, the requirements for STR and DP are minimums. A creature must be strong enough to "lift itself" (the requirement that each +5 BLD have a corresponding +1 STR) and it must be "appropriately tough" for its size (the requirement that each pt of BLD have a corresponding Damage Point). However, those are minimums.

Creatures with Unarmed Size (like giant superheroes or, like, horses) will be either cheaper, stronger, or have more DP than their equally sized Armed brethren. I need to decide what I'm going to do about that--and it's probably going to be some combination of the three. Testing shows that Unarmed characters can be cheaper and stronger (although they must, of course, keep the BLD the same since that's what you are buying).

What About CON, +'s TBH, Stride, and Reach?
It looks like those will come off a table and you'll index your size (BLD) and Total AP and see what the cost is for these "extras." As bonuses To-Be-Hit are bad for you, this may well wind up be negative points (you get points back)--or maybe we can just give you more DP (my preferred position) and that's what you'll be looking up.

I'm not sure yet.


End Note
I'm still doing some testing--but one consequence of an ability that adds DP as well as Damage is that the ALL ARMOR guy comes out way, way better than the others for reasons I'm not entirely clear on (well, I'm mostly clear--the ALL DP guy gets an additional multiplier for his DP that does not apply to the Size DP granted). I'm still running the scripts for the 16, 32, and 64 AP levels.

-Marco

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Success Points

I'm back from comic con! Today I'll be testing toxins, spines (like a porcupine's quills--it attacks you when you attack them!), and pincer (a grab/worry style attack).

I got a series of questions from a reader to work on. I'm starting here with Success Points. But before that ... a quick note on Disease.

Disease
We actually have had some notes on disease at various places in the rules. The problem with disease is that (a) it's seriously un-fun but moreover (b) it serves some very strange purposes in RPG-play. I love the nasty colorful diseases from Warhammer. If we do a dark fantasy game it'll probably have some notes. Diseases can be a sort of slow wasting that spur PCs to action (we must save the prince by getting a healer!) or they can be simple 'realistic' hazards of injury or environment (don't go down in the sewers, you'll get skin-rot!). If a PC is diseased then usually it means either (a) it's part of their character and is long term of (b) it's simply an obstacle that has to be overcome in the short term. I suspect dying of disease would be very unsatisfying.

Finally there's the carrier issue: in a post-apocalyptic wasteland it might be cool to have a disease carrier character who would spread doom on towns he crossed (or, you know, maybe those who spilled his blood?).

In any event the issue is two fold: the first is a question of infection. The deadliness of a disease is not proportional to its infectiousness. In fact, the really deadly diseases are probably harder to catch than the other way around. JAGS Disease rules will need a way to handle infection apart from the actual effects. This would likely be a CON roll modified by the disease itself and circumstance (if you bathe in it, roll at -4).

The effects themselves (once you have it) would indeed be a Resisted Attack with long-term effects (most diseases will not kill you during combat). The rules for curing would likely be a Resisted Attack roll vs. some portion of the initial Intensity based on the Result (i.e. a Catastrophic Result might be 3x the initial Intensity, while a Minor Result might be 1/4).

There is probably a note for each level at how often the PC has to re-roll their defenses hoping to get better but possibly getting worse. These are complex rules and would need at least a page or two in order to be covered. They're low priority for the next release.

Success Points
Success Points are fairly new to JAGS and they exist because of a couple of specific needs. These are:

  • A way to measure the progress of a Drama Roll. A Drama Roll is a series of rolls (usually 3), where the amount each roll is made by is tracked against a Target Number. So, for example, if your safe-cracker is working on the safe (and gets one roll every 20 min) and they need a total of 20 SPs to crack it, over a given time they can likely eventually crack the safe--but each 20 min it's likely something happens (roll for a guard to come by?). This creates DRAMA!
  • A 'meta-currency' in the game which can be expended during play to make the character more effective. For example, a character with the trait Loser has Success Points and can loan them to other players. The PC, as seen by others, is a bit of a hapless dork--but his or her friends get "buffs" from being around them. This is sort of like Xander in Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
These are two different things and they (confusingly) share the same name.

What Are We Going To Do?
Well, it's very possible that we'll change the name of one of the two things. I'm open to suggestions. However, as the two are somewhat inter-related let's discuss in more detail how they should work.

Do You Get SPs From a Drama?
If the safe-cracker in the example above needs 20 SPs to crack the safe and generates 30 does the character keep the other 10? No. You don't. SPs generated for a drama are lost when the drama ends. That, however, is not the whole story: sometimes the point of a Drama is to generate SPs. Huh? Let's take a look:

Trait: Con Man. The character can run "confidence games" to generate money and SPs which they can later use. In this case the con itself is a drama: the PC must beat a Target Number with three rolls to successfully pull off a Con against a mark. If they succeed they get some money and they get 2 SPs! A Con Man has a "battery" of 4 SPs per level.
What does the above mean? Let's break it down

  1. The trait itself will be a Generic Archetype Trait and will cost 4 or 8 AP per level. It grants a "special ability" to generate SPs through Con Games. NOTE: you do NOT need Con Man to run a con game. Anyone can do that. You don't even, necessarily, need Con Artist skill although without it you will be hugely disadvantaged since the GM can't assume you get things correct when you don't specify them. What the Trait does is grant the PC the ability to generate SPs that they can use for other things (possibly "whatever roll they want to improve").
  2. The rules will sketch out a general drama for a con game. Any PC with the right skills can do it. Again, you don't need the Trait to try to con someone. What changes if you do have the trait is that you get, in addition to money, SPs for it.
  3. When a character with the Trait does the drama and succeeds all the SPs generated by the Con Artist skill rolls will go away (poof!) but if successful the character will then GET 2 SPs to mark on their sheet. These can then be used for other rolls or whatever.
  4. We are working on the concept of a "battery." This limits how many SPs the character can walk around with (4 per level) and answers the question: "how many SPs does an NPC with the Con Man Trait have?" NPCS are generally assumed to be either half or fully loaded.
What Can You Use SPs For?
This is tricker than it sounds--we do have some rules for this in the book ... but ...
  1. The general rule is that you can only spend SPs if you made the roll. The SPs just make it better. This is done because we want your roll to be important in the game--moreso than SPs.
  2. Can you "buff" someone else's roll? Often yes. We expect many SP-pools to be able to be lent to other characters. This is a good way of handling certain meta-game things like a commander who improves his men's abilities.
  3. What about restricting SPs to certain kinds of rolls? We plan on it. Imagine a magical sword that gives 3 SPs for dealing more damage or getting around a block. That's offensive. What about a magical shield that gives 4 SPs for making a block with it more likely to work or improving what a CON roll was made by. Those are defensive. There are several other possibilities (a lab that generates SPs for science rolls?) 
  4. How do SPs effect Resisted Rolls? We need to determine this because those rolls are important and SPs need to have impact. Likely an SP can improve the roll by 1 per pt spent? Something like that?
When Do You Use SPs?
We need to understand how big a deal SPs are by testing in the simulator. This will be especially key for magical treasure. Here are some "use cases"/scenarios that I foresee for SP usage.

Offensive
  • Improve hit-by to 4+ for PEN damage. The character will only spend SP when the hit is by +0 to +3 and will get it up to +4.
  • Hit Around Armor. The character will spend SP on any roll that hits to hit around plate armor.
  • Get Around Block. The character will spend SP to get around a block. How does this happen when dealing with the defender spending SPs as well? Does it go back and forth? I'm not 100% sure.
  • Reduce Armor Save. Each SP will reduce an Armor Save by 1pt. The character will spend the Armor Save down to an 8- if possible.
Defensive
  • Make block work. When the block roll is made but not by enough SPs will be spent to shore it up.
  • Improve CON roll. SPs are spent to move a CON roll towards No Effect.
  • Improve Armor Save. The character can spend SPs at +1 to the Armor Save for 1 SP before the roll is made to ensure it will be made. The character will always spend up to a 12- if they have the SPs.
What Else?
There could be SP pools that regenerate during combat (the sword recharges every time it kills an enemy) and so on. We should think on that (what if the shield recharges when it Blocks five attacks?).

Wednesday, July 21, 2010

On Hold For Comic Con

I'll be doing updates when I get back. Right now I'm on the west coast attending Comic Con so I'm not testing anything. A few notes, however.

Toxin DQI
I discovered that some of the testing I'd done yesterday and the Friday before had a code error that made several different toxins all the same thing. I discovered this when I looked at results for a weak one and a powerful one and they were identical. It took me a while to run it down though.

Toxin Plan
Ideally there would be one "damage dealing toxin" and it would just "scale." In fact, we could probably do this--but I'm less comfortable about that than I am about increasing the Intensity Score. On the other hand, if a toxin does X-damage points at each level then, at a certain AP range, no matter what its Intensity score it'll be irrelevant: imagine a toxin that, at Catastrophic Effect level, does 30 damage: if used on an elephant with 100's of DP, the Intensity isn't really all that relevant. It can score Catastrophic every time and the target elephant won't care all that much.

So what I have done is create a list of toxins (right now 3) from light to heavy doing damage at three different ranges. The idea would be that if these plot well I can either have a "make your own rule" that shows how to extrapolate or I can create one toxin and determine how to scale the damage AND Intensity against APs.

Either way, hopefully this is almost the end of this whole toxin thing.

Toxins Aren't Fun
Jeff pointed out over the weekend that Toxins are not (or are rarely) "fun." PCs aren't known for using poisoned weapons and being poisoned is--just--not. fun. I agree. The discussion about why I'm doing this anyway was interesting.

1. Being poisoned creates a certain kind of dynamic tension. The PC is taking recurring damage and their fellows may need to intervene.  This is interesting in some situations.

2. Facing a toxin-using foe (giant scorpions!) creates a different kind of tension: the character really doesn't want to be hit and each individual toxic strike is more dramatic than just another claw-hit.

3. There's a verisimilitude argument: if my alien has poisoned fangs then I want to be able to simulate that. Even if it's not a big part of the game, it's good to have it.

4. There are a lot of effects that are beneficial to the game that are similar to toxins but not identical. Things like sleep-darts, paralysis gas, and mental attacks all use the same or similar rules. These are definitely good for the game (having cops be able to use 'Tasers' that are properly represented in the rules in a way that is (a) balanced and (b) feels 'right' is something almost no other RPG I am aware of does).

So anyway, that's the reason we're spending so much time on this.

-Marco

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Talking Toxins

One of the hazards of this blog is that I'm going to spend time (DAYS!) talking about stuff that you cannot and (I'll wager) should not give a crap about. In this case: more on toxins.

Today I ran the scripts to test TOXIC CLOUD. Toxic Cloud bypasses all the "draws blood" nonsense and simply hits the target with a Resisted Attack that they must roll against. It's the same thing we had before: it does immediate damage and then continuing damage until they make a CON roll at some negative (usually -1).

Given the JAGS Resisted Attack rules I realized (I saw it yesterday but didn't quite know what to make of it) that there was a problem: the problem is that a given damage-dealing toxin is NOT suitable for all AP Ranges. Let's see what I mean by that:

Average Damage Points vs. Intensity of the Toxin
A check of the 32 AP Herd shows me that the 30%-Attack builds (16 characters) have, on the average, 42 DP. The average for the 4 Weapon-Using members (the 50%-Attack builds that I give a weapon to in order to test it) have, on the average 31 DP.

The Toxic Cloud at the 32 AP level wants a 65 Intensity in order to win 50% of its fights assuming the Toxic Cloud Attack operates at range, gets +2 to hit, and fires twice per Round. According to my calculations that means it has a 16- roll and, if the attacker rolls a 6 or less it'll deal its maximal Catastrophic attack of 24 pts of damage immediately and 8pts of recurring damage. More likely the attacker will roll a 10 and get a MAJOR EFFECT which will do 16 damage followed by 6.

These are all respectable numbers.

But when I outfit the weapon in a "more likely" Breath-Weapon configuration of firing once per Round? It wants an Intensity of 140 (Roll of a 30-) in order to win 45% of the time. In other words, the somewhat meager damage that this particular brand of toxin does will NOT win you a fight (against powerful fists, blades, a .357 equivalent gun, or energy blast) unless it regularly does its maximal effect.

Even worse, the stats for a 'breath weapon' I'd like to have include 1x-per-Round fire and a Cool Down round or even Charge Up (so the Toxic beast can't breathe on the party 1st Round). I know what my simulator will say: probably no amount of Intensity will give that configuration a win.

Not with that toxin.

Other Toxins
Of course I'm free to build any toxin I want. We have a good number of effects to choose from and can integrate even more with a little effort. I can have the toxin simply deal an immediate and fight-winning unconscious/death result. I can have the CRITICAL EFFECT level do a million points of damage. I can play with this however I want.

What we think this means is that there will need to be different schedules of toxin that will be either more or less relevant at differing point levels. The Toxin I have now is good for a fantasy game level: if your fighter gets a really bad CON roll and suffers 24 points of damage he's probably down and maybe out--but it isn't necessarily an instant kill.

On the other hand, if you are building a venomous super-villain or space-marine bad-ass (40K type with, uhm, a super-toxic boomerang gun or something wacky like that) then you could get a "schedule 2" toxin where the critical and catastrophic effects do like 100pts of damage (and Major is much higher too). The simulator should, in fact, balance this for the lower levels as well: the starting Intensity for a 32pt Herd might be more like 20 instead of 65.

However, with this toxin, higher Intensity scores will allow the toxin to be relevant to higher damage classes.

So we'll see. I need to cook some of these up and then test them.

-Marco

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

More Venom!

Today I spent most of the cycles testing various configurations of en-venomed attacks. Everything from 1x-Per-Round (Stinger) to 2x-Per-Round (Poisoned claws) to long-range (Breathe Mustard Gas). I used the same toxin for everything as a level-set.

Here's what I've learned:

  • Indeed, taking a toxin gas against high-armor/low Damage Point targets wipes them out. However, the high-armor guys using the mustard gas are still fighting people (for the most part) with conventional attacks and do very well there. Armor is still king in that scenario.
  • The "draws blood" requirement is, in fact, pretty rare. Over a 3-4 round fight even having a powerful toxin-carrier attack doesn't help that much. I'm not 100% sure why but the PEN damage values came out about where they are for non-envenomed attacks. I think this is because by the time you are doing enough damage to draw blood 40% of the time you are already doing enough damage to win the fight with your PEN attack--so the toxin on top is "just gravy." I examined the fights in strong debug and determined that they did seem to be working.
  • High DP helps a lot against Mustard Gas (and is less effective against the stinger since the stinger does a lot of PEN damage). The win %'s against the high DP guys were like 1-4% while being 88% against all-armor attackers. This is one of those cases where the "average" is fine but the actual components of the average are not. I'm not yet sure what to do about this either. An attack that is very good against many opponents and useless against others is not gearing up for good gaming ...
What Does This All Mean?
Well, it means that I'm going to have to apply some philosophy in pricing chemical attacks. The simulator proves that against our herd their value can be normalized--but I have to carefully consider the ramifications of cheap toxin attacks and where I'd want to see those exist.

-Marco

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Venom

One of the more complex attack types is a carrier venom attack. Think of poisoned fangs, a stinger, or a scorpion's tail. In this case the attack itself may do some damage (a scorpion's tail can kill outright even without the toxin) and, in any event, it has to penetrate armor in order to get the poison into the target's bloodstream.

This means in JAGS Terms:

  1. The attack must be PEN and must hit (duh)
  2. The armor must fail an armor save
  3. At least 1pt of damage or more must get through the target's armor.
These three effects mean the attack has "drawn blood." Then the poison can go to work. There can be more than one kind of poison. First let's review the basics:

Toxins (and other Resisted Attacks)
In the expanded JAGS Archetypes rules Resisted Attacks have a new statistic: Intensity. It works like this: when you are hit with an RA you (or the attacker--the rules specify that the Player usually gets to roll) must make a Resistance Save (using the Resisted Roll rules) comparing:
  • The Intensity score + POWER Stat of the RA to your Damage Points (DP) + Resistance Stat
  • The "POWER Stat" of the RA to the Resistance Stat of yours (usually CON, sometimes WIL). For each point of difference you get a +/- 1 depending on whether your score is higher or not. 
Let's see an example:

A character with CON 12 and 14 DP is hit by a Taser with a POWER stat of 11 and 15 Intensity. The Resisted Attack Roll is: Attacking Taser: 15+11 =26 vs. 14+12 = 26 or a 10-. Then, adjusted for the character's stat (CON) it goes to an 11- Resistance Roll since the PC has a CON of 12 vs. the Taser's Power of 11.
Okay? It's not the simplest thing in the world but it (a) gives PCs with a good stat a substantial edge which is important and (b) distinguishes from, for example, a pepper spray that will work on a teenager vs. one that might work on a bear. Both of these are necessary for the rules to work properly.

The Roll And Effects
Once you make the roll there are five levels of effect: Minor, Standard, Major, Critical, or Catastrophic. To get a Catastrophic roll you have to fail by 10+ so, in the example above, it's not possible with a standard roll unless you treat a 20 (1:1296) as a Catastrophic failure no matter what. For things that are balanced you'll usually see Minor to Major results. That's what we're going for.

However: a Major result for a Death Ray is very much worse than a Major Result for Tear Gas. The viciousness of each result level changes based on the attack type.

Got that? So here's how this thing breaks down ...

How Resisted Attacks Get Analyzed
Firstly there is their chance to effect at all. In the case of a blood-toxin (as opposed to a gas or "ray") the general power of the carrier (the stinger) is important: how likely is it to draw blood?

Then there's the matter of POWER and Intensity: against a given character point level we can more or less estimate what DP will be and what their stat will be (we assume a CON of 12 for most characters).

Then we need to know how bad a given result is. Many results are "simple." For example with the Death Ray you just take a Wound's worth of DP and make the appropriate Wound Roll. However for some attacks, such as Paralysis toxin, you can suffer lost REA or Initiative for several Rounds. There are negatives Perception Modifiers (for blinding attacks) and Skill Roll negatives ... and so on. There is also additional damage and in some cases it continues for several rounds.

This is all very complex and trying to figure out what the numbers and effects should be is hugely difficult. Thankfully we have the simulator.

What I'm Testing
I started out by taking a baseline and running a test for "Lance," a medium reach PEN HTH attack that hit only once per Round (the theory being that most toxin attacks like Scorpion Tail or Fangs are once-a-Round types of things anyway). Then I created a Toxin attack using one of the basic damage-dealing toxins. I'm running a set of tests now to see how well they'll compare.

I don't know the results yet--but here's an interesting note: usually the character with maximal armor and only a few DP is, in fact, a superior build against peer opponents (although he crumbles faster against slightly more powerful opponents). In this case, once the damage is sufficient to penetrate with any regularity his values are reversed: he loses more often than a moderately armored character with more DP--he's more susceptible to the venom.

Additional Note
Just like IQ Tests measure "how well you take the test" (even though we'd all like them to measure 'how smart you are') our methodology measures "how good this is in the simulator" vs. how-good-this-is in the game. Want an example? Compare Sleep Dart to NeuroToxin Dart.

In the case of the Sleep Dart this is a very powerful attack in terms of result: the Minor Result Dazes you. Everything else knocks you out. It's what you see in the movies: thuck ... thud. Because the results are so bad the Power and Intensity is quite low: if you are going to take out a peer with a sleep dart you either better get lucky or have a lot of your points in it. On the other hand, sleep darts are good for taking out guards and other less potent characters (this is a feature).

So the simulator measures that perfectly.

Next we go to Neuro-Toxin Dart. It has the same Power and Intensity as the Sleep Dart--but the results go: Minor = Dazed, Everything Else = Dead. In the simulator it costs ... the exact same amount (the simulator stops the fight at Unconscious and doesn't care if the target is down or dead). This is one of those philosophical questions: how much is the assassin dart worth than the sleep dart.

Consider that, for a character with murderous intent, in a 1-on-1 fight, putting a target to sleep is the same as killing them if they have a few extra seconds (in most cases, anyway). However, on the other hand, a group of PCs going up against a cyborg assassin who fires shellfish venom darts is a hell of a lot more scared than going up against a cyborg with a tranq gun: so long as the PCs enjoy an advantage in the fight they are not facing roll-or-die (and that's assuming the tranq gun character even wants to kill them).

So ... how much? I have some ideas but I don't really know the answer yet.

-Marco
 

Monday, July 12, 2010

Swimming in JAGS

I periodically get emailed questions about the JAGS rules. I do my best to answer them but I know why one of the Champion Designers (I think it was Aaron Allston) wore a shirt that said "I am not a Champions guru." It turns out that not only is my head full of JAGS rules, it's full of several editions of JAGS rules including the copy-shop bound early versions that you'll never see (I don't think I even have any anymore). It's full of various corrections and revisions of the current rules. It's full of stuff I wanted to put in and didn't. It's full of discussions and arguments I've had with the other people who've helped me with it.

When W.S. asked me if there were swimming rules my only thought was "search the PDF. It's what I'd have to do."

Apparently it turns up NOTHING. So let's take a look.

You Complete The Game
The 1st edition of Gamma World had GM's notes that explained that the Game Master "completed" the game. I love this idea. They meant that the act of making an actual scenario was, in a way, "completing" the game--sort of--even if just a little--like making a new set of rules. Of course I don't think the original Gamma World had any rules for swimming either and that didn't mean no mutant could ever swim. If there needed to be rules the GM would be expected to "complete the game" and come up with some.

Here's What I Did (and Would Expect You To Do)
While I was watching Eclipse with my wife this weekend--about the third time or more that the werewolf with the great abs got stalkerfific with the fang-banging emo-girl I started thinking about swimming in JAGS. How would I do it? the question breaks down into a few parts:

  1. What are the (general) rules for being submerged? What are things like movement rates when swimming and things like that?
  2. What does a character need to have in order to swim?
  3. What differentiates a dog-paddling swimmer from Michael Phelps?
In order to figure this out--and these are not "official rules"--I used the universal ubiquitous data-library: Google. I also just applied some general thinking to get rules for the first question.

Rules For Being Submerged/Swimming
Clearly being in the water is hard for people who don't know what they're doing. Plus, they can drown. Movement rates will be slowed, people are easier to hit, and you can suffocate. Also: water would protect you from incoming strikes and stuff.

  • Unless you are an aquatic creature or have some special trait, you lose your AGI bonus in the water.
  • Unless you have some special traits you must spend 5 REA per Round "swimming" or sink. You can hold position (assuming you can swim) or keep on moving or start moving (which will cost you 8) but unless you want to sink, you pay 5 REA at the start of the Round or down you go.
  • Water will make most strikes inefficient. Let's say it confers a -6 Damage Modifier to all attacks (mostly submerged characters get Coverage of 4 that will either result in a miss (simple) or a -6 DM).
  • Knives and spears and other "aquatic weapons" don't suffer this modifier or any modifier at all.
  • If you start drowning you probably fight at -4 unless you make a WIL roll by 4 or more each Round. Skill levels can negate some of this. You can hold your breath for CON Rounds if doing very little but combat is taxing: if you can't breathe water you will start drowning if completely submerged on the 2nd round of combat (assuming you don't spend 5 REA to keep your head above water).
  • A successful grapple can hold someone under water.
  • After your time is up, at the end of the next Round you are unconscious and dying.
How Fast Do You Move?
I asked Google "How Fast Do People Swim" and got a link that said most people at a leisurely pace go .8km per hour. Google calculator (like, the best thing I've ever seen) says that's .24 yards per second or .75 yards per move action. Let's kick that up: an untrained person swims at 1 yard per second for Walking Endurance. 

This is a great link because it goes further to say that if you are determined--but not an athlete--you go at about 2 miles per hour or, doing the JAGS math, 3 yards per movement action. That's Sprinting Endurance.

Finally, it goes to professional athletes. The numbers come out to a top speed of about 6 yards per second as a top contender: being highly trained about doubles your speed.

How Do You Purchase It?
This is a great question. Clearly the generic Sports Skill could be Professional Swimming. So, hey, that way? Well, no--that's not the whole story. My daughter can swim and she sure doesn't have 2 CP invested in swimming (even at L1). I can swim better and I don't have points invested either. While there is a Swimming Skill (in theory) you don't need it to swim a little: that doesn't make sense.

Why not? Well, the obvious answer is "most people can swim with a lot less training than it takes to, say, learn Karate." Even more to the point though: if the game is (somehow) about professional swimmers (I once ran a game where a PC was on a high school volleyball team) then you want the skill to differentiate skill levels in competition. It's fine for that. If a PC wants to be a really strong expert swimmer then, okay, invest the points in the Sports Skill--that's what it's there for--but not only does a strong investment fail the reality check, it fails the good game design check. Forcing anyone who might go near water to spend 2-3 CP or risk death is just a bad call ... and, really, vanishingly few characters in fiction are distinguished "by the fact that they can swim."

So How DO You Purchase It?
Well, a look at the all-knowing Wikipedia under Swimming suggests that in the UK kids who can't swim 25 meters get about 10 hours of remedial training. That isn't much in the grand scheme of things (further pointing out that it shouldn't be a skill for most people). Let's go to the book and see if there's an example.

I cite the limitation "Lousy Driver" (pg 83, I looked it up). In game-worlds where there is an assumption of competence then the lack of the skill becomes a negative point Trait (a defect). So, say, for modern day it's -1 for Can't Swim. Something like that.

In game worlds where there is no presumption then it could be a skill (but probably not an Expensive one unless you are a sport swimmer). So say it's a Normal-cost Skill for medieval Europe and an exotic one. A Level 1 ability in it would give basic survival level swimming. Higher levels would make you a little faster, give some resistance to negatives, and so on.

Alternatively you could just make it a 1 CP Trait "Knows How To Swim" and call it a day.

What About The Sport Skill?
A look at a couple of competitive swimming pages show that there are some special skills around the start, the flip-turn. Without further research, I would assume that the skill there gives advantages measured in seconds or less to the better practitioner. There's also military swimming mentioned which (I assume) trains for holding breath, intel-gathering, and setting up explosives underwater. Maybe you wire them to the trained dolphin or something ... I don't know.

Anyway, all of this is handled by the Sport Skill. In a competition the characters will be having a Drama Roll session to see who can generate the most SPs. Having a roll requires the skill (if you just had the Normal Skill you probably couldn't get more than 1SP for making it--probably at a -3).

So that's still an option if you want to play Michael Phelps.

-Marco (I'll answer his other question later)